[Stoves] 5 USD per this armful sized bundle of fuelwood of softpine fuelwood

Andrew C. Parker acparker at xmission.com
Fri Mar 16 01:34:06 CDT 2012


Dr. Karve,

The introduction of exotic pests and diseases through the transport of  
plants or plant tissue has historically had devastating consequences.  The  
devastation may be rare, but it is still devastation.  I don't consider it  
to be unreasonable to practice caution when importing biomass, be it a  
pile of wood chips from the local landfill, a Christmas tree from Idaho or  
Pennsylvania, bundled pine from Oregon or bundled hardwood from China or  
India.  No doubt such caution may be manipulated by politicians and  
protectionists, but that does not negate the need for caution.

My father was a microbiologist.  One of his little sayings was "you can't  
buy time."  He said that in the context of human disease and the  
politicization of public health.  You can throw millions at an emerging  
disease, but if you make no attempt to contain it through testing and  
quarantines, you lose time, and laboratory research takes time.

Perhaps torrefaction, along with its other benefits, could be effective in  
sanitizing biomass prior to shipping?


Respectfully,

Andrew Parker (Not AJH)


On Thu, 15 Mar 2012 22:48:28 -0600, Anand Karve <adkarve at gmail.com> wrote:

> Dear Stovers,
> transport of insect pests from different geographic regions is happening
> all the time but the instance of the exotic pest becoming a pest in the
> host country is rather rare. It happens occasionally and these examples  
> are
> blown out of proportion to scare people away from importing biomass and
> plants from other areas of the world. In nature there are about 100,000
> species of insects that can be considered to be phytophagous. Take a look
> at any plant species, and one finds not 100,000 species of insects on it
> but only 5 or 6. This is because all plants have their own inherent
> insecticides in their cells, which protect them from most of the insect
> pests in the world. Only those 5 or 6 insect species that have evolved  
> the
> capacity to digest that particular poison can survive on that plant
> species. That is also the reason why the pests of plants are specific to
> each species. One never finds the pests of mustard on tomato, or the  
> pests
> of tomato on corn. Therefore, if an insect pest gets into the USA from
> India, it won't survive in the USA, because the specific host required by
> that insect would not be available to it in the USA. That is also the
> reason why exotic plant species thrive well in other habitats. Take, for
> instance, Eucalyptus introduced from Australia into other parts of the
> world. The local insect pests in the host country are unable to feed on
> Eucalyptus, which therefore grows in the host country without any natural
> enemies.
> Yours
> A.D.Karve




More information about the Stoves mailing list